You had a big storm last night. One or more sections of your roof may have suffered damage. Shingles blew off, or a branch crashed into one side of your house and damaged shingles. It’s likely not a big deal. In most cases, you probably just need to replace those shingles or repair a small area. But you want to make sure that the underlayment or the roof deck is in good shape before you replace shingles because there could be other damage that might cause problems in the future.

If you have been in this type of situation, you may be wondering about roof replacement or repair. Which one is the better option? This blog post will help you find the answer.

Roof Replacement or Repair: Which One Should You Choose?

Ultimately, you have to decide. It depends on how damaging the damage is and how much money you want to spend.

If you want to save some cash, you can always repair the roof damage yourself or hire a handyman to do the job. If the problem is minor, repairing the damage may be the best choice.

On the other hand, if your roof is in very bad shape, you may want to consider roof replacement. It’s sometimes a better option because it can be cheaper than roof repair. If you want to keep your roof in tip-top shape, roof replacement is a good idea, especially if you have to replace your whole roof sooner or later.

These are the biggest pros and cons of roof replacement and roof repair.

Pros of Roof Replacement

Roof replacement is a cheaper option, especially if the whole roof needs replacement. Sometimes it can save you up to 50% off the cost of a new roof. If your roof deck is in good shape, you don’t have to replace it. Only the shingles will be replaced.

Cons of Roof Replacement

Some homeowners think that removing and replacing the entire roof is a lot of work. It can be time-consuming, and it requires some skill. It could also be dangerous if you are working on a ladder.

Pros of Roof Repair

Roof repair is easier and quicker than roof replacement. It’s easier to do it on your own, and it requires minimal skills. Some roof repair is also cheaper than complete roof replacement.

Cons of Roof Repair

Minor roof repair often leads to bigger problems. It’s not always a good idea to do it on your own. If your roof has a big hole, it may be more expensive than replacing it. Sometimes it also requires a new roof deck.


Roof replacement or repair: which one should you choose? Before you make any decision, inspect your roof. Get a professional inspection and make a decision based on the recommendations of your inspection report.

There is no right or wrong answer. It all depends on your situation. If you are looking for an inexpensive replacement for your roof, then a roof repair is the right choice for you. If you need a new, beautiful roof, then a roof replacement is the right choice.

Whether you opt for replacement or repair on your roof, working with a professional is a must. Visit Rankin Roofing and Solar for all your roofing needs. We offer a wide range of the best roofing and solar services while providing an unmatched customer experience. Experience the difference when you work with Rankin Roofing and Solar!

solar panelSolar Panel Orientation and Position: Why It is Important
Get Your Free Roof Inspection TODAY!

Are You Looking For The Best Local Roofing Contractor?